Best Pizza in Pompton Plains

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Pompton Plains, NJ at 569 NJ-23

Pizza, Subs, Dinners, and More Since 1998

Order online

Featured

View menu

Family-Owned for 27 years

For 27 years, Stefano's Pizzeria Pompton Plains has been the neighborhood go-to for pizza, hot subs, sandwiches, wraps, and Italian dinners. The Stefano family keeps things simple: fresh ingredients, big portions, and friendly faces behind the counter. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice on your lunch break, picking up a pie for the family, or sitting down for a full dinner, we've got you covered. Our regulars know us for our crispy pizza, overstuffed subs, and homemade desserts like cannoli and gelato. Stop in, call ahead, or order online for pickup and delivery. We're here to make your day a little easier and a lot more delicious.

Your Neighborhood Pizzeria

Stefano's Pizzeria at 569 NJ-23 in Pompton Plains is where locals come for pizza, subs, sandwiches, wraps, and Italian dinners. Whether you're swinging by for a quick slice, grabbing lunch to go, or sitting down with the family for dinner, we keep it fresh, fast, and affordable. Dine in, take out, or get it delivered.

Dine In, Take Out, or Grab and Go

Whether you want to sit down and enjoy a meal, call ahead for pickup, or swing by for a quick slice, Stefano's makes it easy. Our clean, comfortable spot is great for a family dinner, a quick lunch, or hanging out with friends on the patio. No fuss, just good food and friendly service.

Visit Stefano's Pizzeria Today

Stop by Stefano's at 569 NJ-23 in Pompton Plains for pizza, subs, wraps, and Italian dinners. We're open Tuesday through Saturday 10am to 10pm and Sunday 12pm to 9pm. Dine in, grab a slice to go, order takeout, or get delivery. See why the neighborhood keeps coming back.

We accidentally found this restaurant while stopping for gas. I was so excited when I saw how cute it was from the outside and nothing disappointed. We brought home three cannolis to share and although I have not tried one yet, I am certain they are going to be excellent! The pizza crust was perfect!

Shelley W.

Absolutely amazing experience! The service was friendly and attentive from the moment we walked in. The food was delicious — you can really taste the quality and care in every dish. We finished our meal with their homemade gelato and cannoli, and both were out of this world! Easily one of the best Italian spots.

Cveti

Had a great experience at this pizzeria! The food was super tasty, fresh, and full of flavor. The staff was really friendly and made sure everything was perfect. It’s the kind of place where you feel welcome as soon as you walk in. Definitely coming back!

Tobias C.

My wife and i were hungry before going into the Goodwill store so we decided to have lunch. The slices were really good. The inside of the place was spotless and the best part was the Gelato after lunch! It was excellent. We would definitely come back.

Louis F.

Featuring

Delivery

Takeout

Catering

Dine In

Outdoor Seating

Vegan Options

Wi-Fi

Gluten-Free

Stefano's Pizzeria Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!

Join Stefano's Pizzeria Rewards

Catering

Let us cater your next event. Click below to get started.

Order catering

Hand-Crafted Gelato

Rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor — our gelato is made the old-world way. From classic pistachio and stracciatella to seasonal specialties, every scoop is crafted fresh with the finest ingredients. Stop in and treat yourself. Because life is too short for anything less than real gelato. Come in today and discover your new favorite flavor.

Cannoli So Good, You'll Come Back for More

Crispy shell. Silky sweet ricotta filling. A little bit of magic in every bite. Our cannoli are made fresh daily, the traditional Sicilian way — never sitting, never stale, always perfect. Whether you grab one on your way out or order a dozen for the table, our cannoli are the perfect ending to any meal. Ask about our cannoli trays for catering and special events.

More Than Just Pizza

Beyond our hand-tossed pies, we serve hot and cold subs, wraps, chicken dinners, veal, seafood, and homemade pasta. Try the Chicken Stella Mare or grab a Veal Tucano for a full Italian dinner. Looking for something quick? Our sandwiches and wraps are perfect for lunch on the go.

Explore Our Menu

Order Ahead for Pickup or Delivery

Skip the wait and order your favorite pizza, subs, or dinners online. Great for busy weeknights, lunch breaks, or feeding a crowd. Place your order in minutes and grab it on the go, or have it delivered right to your door.

Order Now

📸 Fresh Pizza, Subs, Dinners, and More

From hand-tossed pizza and overstuffed subs to chicken, seafood, and pasta dinners, everything is made fresh daily. Grab a quick bite or sit down for a full meal.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are you known for?

We are known for Caesar Wrap, Tortellini, Gnocchi, Grilled Chicken, Cheesesteak Subs, White Pizza, Spaghetti, Blt, Tortellini In Brodo, Focaccia, Wraps, Gelato, Veggie Wrap, Caprese, Cannoli, Garlic Bread, Cheesecake, Margherita Pizza, Risotto, Mozzarella Sticks, Prosciutto, Wings, Calzone, Bolognese, Chicken Sandwich, Buffalo Chicken Wrap, Philly Cheesesteak, Pasta, Subs, Sandwiches, Philly Cheesesteak Wrap, Cheesesteak, Garlic Knots, Chicken Caesar Wrap, Meatballs, Grilled Chicken Salad, Grilled Chicken Wrap, Chicken Wraps, Spaghetti Carbonara, Stromboli, Meatball Sub, Carbonara, Bruschetta, Caesar Salad, Dessert, Cheese Pizza, Caprese Salad, Salads, Ravioli, Tiramisu, Calamari, Tuna Wrap, Chicken Parm, Lasagna, and Chicken Salad

What meals do you serve?

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Do you offer delivery or takeout?

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

Where are you located?

We are located in Pompton Plains, NJ at 569 NJ-23

What areas do you serve?

We serve the following areas: Pequannock, Pompton Plains, Wayne, Pompton, Riverdale, Pompton Lakes, Pines Lake, Packanack Lake, Lincoln Park, Preakness, Butler, Mountain View, Paterson, Towaco, Bloomingdale, Oakland, Franklin Lakes, William Paterson University of New Jersey, Wanaque, and Montville.